LHBL2003

The problem already arose with the first version of 6.10. There are no problems with any 6.9 version. We have 10 QNAP NAS systems and not a single system has a problem with Samba. Not even when using ACL. A newly installed 6.10.x only causes problems. A newly installed 6.9.x causes no problems.

I have a feedback that the support is analysing this issue. ————- Re: Re: Unraid User Bug Report (ID #3918) Denis, Please be patient while we work through these issues. As you can appreciate, Microsoft is continually making changes to SMB to address security and the Samba team is doing its best to keep up with those changes. Unraid is the tail being wagged by the dog. We come in after the fact and do what we can to address the changes in SMB and Samba. We do a lot of internal testing and RC releases to try to get as much addressed as possible before release. AD is an enterprise feature and we have limited internal capability to test. That being said, we are working on this issue. Dan

I could provide a VMWare test system. Consisting of AD, Client and Unraid. So that you can jointly investigate the error on a system. I could provide access via TeamViewer. Snapshots can also be used to reset changes. However, that would be with an unraid test license. Because if the support doesn't actively help, I won't buy a license. Maybe we'll get a license for the analysis that allows for a longer test period. But the support would have to actively report here first. To everyone involved, what do you think of a common test system?

My last mail to the support. Either you get active help, or I'll get rid of the mix disks and buy a big RAID and carry on as before. —————— Hi Dan, thank you very much that you seem to have released version 6.11. From what I've read, this version is mainly for system improvements and less for new features. I think this is very good, because new functions are useless if existing ones don't work properly. The first one could already find out in the forum that the Samba theme still does not work in this new version either. I and all Windows users would be happy if support actively participated in the topic in the forum mentioned. There are some active people there who will no doubt help you with the error analysis. As others have mentioned in the post, UNRAID is a very nice system. Personally, I'm happy that you can use different hard drives. But without rights management with a Windows directory, this system cannot be used in schools and companies. For this reason, I would like to ask you to take an active part in the contribution. I don't want to play silent mail to somehow try to give support information, only to send half information to them shortly afterwards. The fact is that we have all had problems assigning rights with Windows AD in combination with Unraid since version 6.10. But no problems with other systems such as QNAP. Kind regards denis ———- Hi LHBL2003, psychofaktory has posted a comment on a report, [6.10.3] Intermittent SMB Issues After 6.10.2 Upgrade Posted in [6.10.3] Intermittent SMB Issues After 6.10.2 Upgrade So there seems to be no difference to my configuration here. But why it isn't working as expected here? By the way, the problem still ex... Go to this Report Comment https://forums.unraid.net/bug-reports/stable-releases/6103-intermittent-smb-issues-after-6102-upgrade-r2028/page/3/?tab=comments#

From support: [email protected] DanL has replied to your support request. Re: Re: Unraid User Bug Report (ID #3918) Hello, There is a potential solution here: https://forums.unraid.net/bug-reports/stable-releases/log-file-idmap_hash_initialize-the-idmap_hash-module-is-deprecated-and-should-not-be-used-r1501/?tab=comments&comment=20593&do=findComment#comment-20593 Please review that solution and see if it applies to your situation. Dan — Unraid

I had on 25.07. opened a ticket: Unraid User Bug Report (ID #3918) the support is aware of this entry. I asked again to support the post. Since apparently no progress can be seen without further help. I hope we will get support soon.

Attention ⚠️ the actual problem will be discussed in another post. a solution was also proposed. I haven't had the time to test this yet. but here are the links: https://forums.unraid.net/bug-reports/stable-releases/6103-intermittent-smb-issues-after-6102-upgrade-r2028/ Jump to the not yet tested instructions: https://forums.unraid.net/bug-reports/stable-releases/6103-intermittent-smb-issues-after-6102-upgrade-r2028/?do=findComment&comment=20213

So I installed Unraid 2 days ago (version 6.10.3 2022-06-14) and lifted it into our Windows domain. AD initial owner: Administrators_xyz AD initial group: Administrators_xyz I can access the share with users from this group. Even if "everyone" has no rights. I have created a group using the path described in the link. https://www.linuxserver.io/blog/2015-07-20-how-to-active-directory-on-unraid-6 Then I assigned a test user to the ReadWrite group. Result: No authorisation. The domain server wnter "Effective Access" says that the user has full rights. If I add Full Access under Permissions for Everyone, the user immediately gets access to the share. Apparently the manually added groups do not work. Yes, I have re-registered the user after he has been assigned the groups.