March 14, 20242 yr Community Expert 9 minutes ago, dlandon said: Install the recycle bin plugin and be sure it is running. In my testing it looks like file deletes work. Yep, it also works for me.
March 14, 20242 yr Author 24 minutes ago, dlandon said: I seem to have found a get around, but I'm baffled right now about why this works. Install the recycle bin plugin and be sure it is running. This sort of works for me, but it isn't working in a Test share that I have .txt files in to test deleting, but deleted some other files fine.
March 14, 20242 yr Community Expert 21 minutes ago, aqua said: but it isn't working in a Test share that I have .txt files Strange, the test I made also was with txt files, and it worked for me.
March 14, 20242 yr 1 hour ago, aqua said: This sort of works for me, but it isn't working in a Test share that I have .txt files in to test deleting, but deleted some other files fine. This might be affected by the excluded files in the recycle bin. As I mentioned already, this is a very bizare get around and I don't expect it to work in all cases. It's going to end up being up to the samba development team to find the final solution.
March 14, 20242 yr 1 hour ago, dlandon said: This might be affected by the excluded files in the recycle bin. As I mentioned already, this is a very bizare get around and I don't expect it to work in all cases. It's going to end up being up to the samba development team to find the final solution. Can you share your log into the bugzilla issue. If it's not the same as should open an new one. Thx a lot
June 15, 20242 yr Any update on this, it is still an issue with 6.12.10 and recycle bin would be great if it could monitor and delete stuff immediately but it can't so I either have to wait an hour or go in the web UI to run it manually.
July 3, 20242 yr Because beta version 7 is out now, see here: Is this issue solved? (so i dont have to activate old samba protocoll?) thx
July 23, 20241 yr On 7/3/2024 at 9:03 AM, pOpYRaid said: Because beta version 7 is out now, see here: Is this issue solved? (so i dont have to activate old samba protocoll?) thx https://docs.unraid.net/unraid-os/release-notes/7.0.0/ samba: version 4.20.2 https://www.samba.org/samba/history/samba-4.20.2.html There seems to be some changes but I'm not sure if it relates to solving this error. * BUG 15659: Segmentation fault when deleting files in vfs_recycle. /BR Edited July 23, 20241 yr by TateM
August 22, 20241 yr On 7/26/2024 at 10:26 AM, pOpYRaid said: I have tested it with the beta, sadly the issue is not gone. @pOpYRaid Do you have the recycle bin active? It appears there are two issues. The initial error appears to be due to Bug 15527; this was fixed in 4.20.0 and backported to 4.19.6. 4.20.1 introduced a new issue, Bug 15659; which I'm guessing is triggered by the recycle plugin workaround. Unfortunately I don't have a spare server to verify with the 7.0 beta.
August 23, 20241 yr @tkenn1s thx for clearing things up. my beta 2 of unraid 7 is running samba 4.20.2. No, i have not installed the recycle bin plugin. Any other ideas. It seems to be related to specific android file managers, i am using solid explorer for years and sadly it affects it. Any other hint's i can tighten up security by using SAMB 2/3 with solid explorer?
August 23, 20241 yr FINALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Solid Explorer Dev. fixed that issue on 17.08.2024 with version 2.8.46, see here: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=pl.solidexplorer2 I was in contact with him and sent some logs during reproducing the issue (deletion of an file on unraid on SMB 2/3). Tested it with the new version stating "SMB client improvements" and it works! No more errors! Just wanted you (Solid Explorer) users know.
August 23, 20241 yr Author 1 hour ago, pOpYRaid said: Solid Explorer Dev. fixed that issue on 17.08.2024 with version 2.8.46, see here: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=pl.solidexplorer2 I'm still getting errors on unraid 6.12.11 with solid explorer 2.8.46
August 23, 20241 yr @aqua Interresting! My best advise is to enable debug mode in solid explorer, reproduce the issue and send the report to the dev within the app. Or second: update to unraid 7 beta 2 (which runs flawless for me).
August 23, 20241 yr 9 minutes ago, pOpYRaid said: @aqua Interresting! My best advise is to enable debug mode in solid explorer, reproduce the issue and send the report to the dev within the app. Or second: update to unraid 7 beta 2 (which runs flawless for me). Unfortunately, it doesn't work for me either with the latest Solid Explorer and 7b2. Are you using the Recycle Bin plug-in? Also, would you mind sharing your SMB settings and custom parameters (if any)?
August 23, 20241 yr Here are my solid explorer settings: And the unraid settings: Advanced settings (for hardening): #hardening SMB standalone server server min protocol = SMB3_11 client ipc min protocol = SMB3_11 client signing = mandatory server signing = mandatory client ipc signing = mandatory client NTLMv2 auth = yes smb encrypt = required restrict anonymous = 2 null passwords = No raw NTLMv2 auth = no but also without any advanced settings i can delete files without an issue with solid explorer now.
August 23, 20241 yr 55 minutes ago, pOpYRaid said: Here are my solid explorer settings: And the unraid settings: Advanced settings (for hardening): #hardening SMB standalone server server min protocol = SMB3_11 client ipc min protocol = SMB3_11 client signing = mandatory server signing = mandatory client ipc signing = mandatory client NTLMv2 auth = yes smb encrypt = required restrict anonymous = 2 null passwords = No raw NTLMv2 auth = no but also without any advanced settings i can delete files without an issue with solid explorer now. I removed the Recycle Bin plug-in and duplicated your settings exactly and still get the error. Have you tried to delete a directory with files and folders inside? Deleting a single file is fine. It's the subdirectories that will give an error.
August 23, 20241 yr Other than pOpyraid, has anyone else got this working? Also, single file deletion and empty directories have always worked. It's deleting directories with multiple files/folders inside that result in the error.
August 23, 20241 yr @jserioyou are right! I have forgotten the issue was just on deleting folders with some files in it. Issue still persists for me, also with 2.8.46 solid explorer. I am so sorry guys for the false alarm! Will contact the dev of solid explorer and ask him how to proceed.
August 23, 20241 yr Author I still have issue deleting individual files, including in solid explorer.
August 23, 20241 yr 2 hours ago, pOpYRaid said: @jserioyou are right! I have forgotten the issue was just on deleting folders with some files in it. Issue still persists for me, also with 2.8.46 solid explorer. I am so sorry guys for the false alarm! Will contact the dev of solid explorer and ask him how to proceed. I doubt they (@Limetech) will ever fix this. They have yet to acknowledge it. I'm tempted to switch back to SMB1 just to get this to work again. It's quite frustrating that this has been going on for the last few years.
December 20, 20241 yr On 8/23/2024 at 8:33 PM, jserio said: I doubt they (@Limetech) will ever fix this. They have yet to acknowledge it. I'm tempted to switch back to SMB1 just to get this to work again. It's quite frustrating that this has been going on for the last few years. Agreed, this issue has been reported multiple times over the last 2+ years without acknowledgement that it's a real issue. @limetech How can we move forward with getting this issue resolved?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.