Just thought I should get another opinion, but am I correct that this drive is starting to fail? It would be the first in the array to do so from old age, but it is also probably the most frequently used.

 

 

turtle-smart-20240122-0700.zip

The last SMART test passed, but it was the short test, run an extended test.

Done.

 

It's passing, but I am concerned because that's 2 read errors (looks like in the same place?) within the last 2-3 weeks. I do not have a lot of experience analyzing smart data, though.

 

Typically when a hard drive has failed for me it's an all at once thing where I just can't pull any data off it whatsoever and/or it's making an awful noise.

turtle-smart-20240124-0844.zip

SMART test passed and the errors are reported for LBA 0, which is outside the data:

 

UNC at LBA = 0x00000000 = 0

 

I would give it a second change, but any more errors replace it.