August 14, 2025Aug 14 I have two unraid machines that I've recently built and I can't get either to join the domain.I've been through pretty much every post both here and elsewhere online that I can find on the topic. I'm now multiple hours / days down, £90 in the hole for 2 starter licences and no further forward. . . I'm posting here as a last ditch attempt before I cut my losses and go back to Ubuntu / TrueNAS / Microsoft Server.Environment:Unraid 1: HP Micro Gen 8, 4x3TB SATA HDD + 1x250GB SATA SSDUnraid 2: Dell R420 (controller flashed to IT mode) 4x6TB SAS + 2x1TB NVMEDomain Controllers are Server 2025 with minimal customization.IP addresses are reserved for the unraid servers and static for the DCs.DNS server on the unraid machines is set to the IP address of the primary DC.These are the excerpts from the log:Aug 14 01:31:33 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: shcmd (6324): /usr/local/emhttp/webGui/scripts/update_accessAug 14 01:31:33 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: Stopping services...Aug 14 01:31:34 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: shcmd (6329): /etc/rc.d/rc.samba stopAug 14 01:31:34 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: Stopping Samba server daemon...Aug 14 01:31:34 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: killall --ns 1872983 smbd nmbd wsdd2 winbinddAug 14 01:31:34 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 wsdd2[1871652]: 'Terminated' signal received.Aug 14 01:31:34 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 wsdd2[1871652]: terminating.Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: Samba server daemon... Stopped.Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: shcmd (6330): rm -f /etc/avahi/services/smb.serviceAug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 avahi-daemon[1869494]: Files changed, reloading.Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 avahi-daemon[1869494]: Service group file /services/smb.service vanished, removing services.Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: Starting services...Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: shcmd (6335): /etc/rc.d/rc.samba startAug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: Starting Samba server daemon...Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: /usr/sbin/smbd -DAug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: /usr/sbin/wsdd2 -d -4Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 wsdd2[1873071]: starting.Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: /usr/sbin/winbindd -DAug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 winbindd[1873075]: [2025/08/14 01:31:35.765268, 0, traceid=1] ../../source3/winbindd/winbindd_util.c:1233(init_domain_list)Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 winbindd[1873075]: Could not fetch our SID - did we join?Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 winbindd[1873075]: [2025/08/14 01:31:35.765324, 0, traceid=1] ../../source3/winbindd/winbindd.c:1175(winbindd_register_handlers)Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 winbindd[1873075]: unable to initialize domain listAug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 rc.samba: Samba server daemon... Started.Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: shcmd (6336): cp /tmp/emhttp/smb.service /etc/avahi/services/smb.serviceAug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 avahi-daemon[1869494]: Files changed, reloading.Aug 14 01:31:35 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 avahi-daemon[1869494]: Loading service file /services/smb.service.Aug 14 01:31:36 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 emhttpd: shcmd (6340): /etc/rc.d/rc.avahidaemon reloadAug 14 01:31:36 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 avahi-daemon[1869494]: Got SIGHUP, reloading.Aug 14 01:31:36 ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1 avahi-daemon[1869494]: Service "ASG-UR-HPMSG8-1" (/services/smb.service) successfully established.Things I've tried:Assessing the domain health - couldn't find any issuesDisabling SMB entirely, then trying againRebooting the machineUsing different user accountsChecked the logs on the domain controllers: Nothing thereThoughts:Samba and Kerberos issue? Not sure how I'd diagnose.I'm by no means a Linux expert, but I know someone who is. . . If there are other things to try, I'm all ears.Thanks in advance.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.