Squid Posted May 8, 2016 Author Share Posted May 8, 2016 I think this plugin is very nice. I can see where it would be helpful when there are issues that a user would not even be aware of. Just updated and found a warning about FTP being enabled. I have found that FTP gets re-enabled on a reboot even if I disable it. This behavior occurs on 6.1.9 and 6.2. I've reported this as a defect. I actually think the FTP should be disabled by default and only enabled if a user enables it. sure... just when I'm about to release it... I'll look at it... I don't think the FTP disabling issue is yours. It is the on FTP settings page. If it is disabled and you reboot, it re-enables. Not related to your plugin. Yeah, I realized that - and you're right - it is a bug in unRaid... keeps getting re-enabled There's actually another way to check. by seeing if the user list is populated. If it is then ftp is actually running. And if its running, then I think my warning should still stand -> disable it (and now remove the valid users) and install a real ftp server that would actually be a ton more secure Quote Link to comment
dlandon Posted May 8, 2016 Share Posted May 8, 2016 I think this plugin is very nice. I can see where it would be helpful when there are issues that a user would not even be aware of. Just updated and found a warning about FTP being enabled. I have found that FTP gets re-enabled on a reboot even if I disable it. This behavior occurs on 6.1.9 and 6.2. I've reported this as a defect. I actually think the FTP should be disabled by default and only enabled if a user enables it. sure... just when I'm about to release it... I'll look at it... I don't think the FTP disabling issue is yours. It is the on FTP settings page. If it is disabled and you reboot, it re-enables. Not related to your plugin. Yeah, I realized that - and you're right - it is a bug in unRaid... keeps getting re-enabled There's actually another way to check. by seeing if the user list is populated. If it is then ftp is actually running. And if its running, then I think my warning should still stand -> disable it (and now remove the valid users) and install a real ftp server that would actually be a ton more secure Yes. It's my understanding that FTP is active and working if it is enabled, and users are defined. Your approach of checking for FTP users is a good check for the time being. With security concerns, and a person not intentionally securing ports with their router, it is still best to not have the FTP daemon running unless the user enables it, sets up users, and takes the steps to secure the ports in their router. Quote Link to comment
Squid Posted May 8, 2016 Author Share Posted May 8, 2016 I think this plugin is very nice. I can see where it would be helpful when there are issues that a user would not even be aware of. Just updated and found a warning about FTP being enabled. I have found that FTP gets re-enabled on a reboot even if I disable it. This behavior occurs on 6.1.9 and 6.2. I've reported this as a defect. I actually think the FTP should be disabled by default and only enabled if a user enables it. sure... just when I'm about to release it... I'll look at it... I don't think the FTP disabling issue is yours. It is the on FTP settings page. If it is disabled and you reboot, it re-enables. Not related to your plugin. Yeah, I realized that - and you're right - it is a bug in unRaid... keeps getting re-enabled There's actually another way to check. by seeing if the user list is populated. If it is then ftp is actually running. And if its running, then I think my warning should still stand -> disable it (and now remove the valid users) and install a real ftp server that would actually be a ton more secure Yes. It's my understanding that FTP is active and working if it is enabled, and users are defined. Your approach of checking for FTP users is a good check for the time being. With security concerns, and a person not intentionally securing ports with their router, it is still best to not have the FTP daemon running unless the user enables it, sets up users, and takes the steps to secure the ports in their router. I've commented out the original code, and once its fixed, I'll reapply it for those versions of unRaid with the fix. Quote Link to comment
Squid Posted May 8, 2016 Author Share Posted May 8, 2016 This thread is now closed, and further comments, suggestions, etc should be posted over here: http://lime-technology.com/forum/index.php?topic=48972.0 Quote Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.