What's the best place for own mounts

[hawihoney 5]

For a test I would like to create own mount points - without Unassigned Devices. What's the best place for the base folder that will hold my own mount points?

 

- /mnt/myOwnFolder ?

- /mnt/cache/system/myOwnFolder ?

- /boot/???/myOwnFolder ?

 

Thanks in advance.

 

[itimpi 201]

5 minutes ago, hawihoney said:

For a test I would like to create own mount points - without Unassigned Devices. What's the best place for the base folder that will hold my own mount points?

 

- /mnt/myOwnFolder ?

- /mnt/cache/system/myOwnFolder ?

- /boot/???/myOwnFolder ?

 

Thanks in advance.

 

I created some for my own use under /mnt/disks as that seemed the least likely to cause problems.    However you will need to recreate the mount points and remount any such devices using either the go file or User Scripts as such mounts do not survive reboots.

[hawihoney 5]

I tried /mnt/disks today for my own mounts. But when I did remove some old one from Unassigned Devices, some, not all, of my own mounts were removed as well. I don't know if this was accidently or by design but it scared me to hell. So, currently I use /mnt/hawi/... but I'm not sure if this ok.

 

[dlandon 273]

29 minutes ago, hawihoney said:

I tried /mnt/disks today for my own mounts. But when I did remove some old one from Unassigned Devices, some, not all, of my own mounts were removed as well. I don't know if this was accidently or by design but it scared me to hell. So, currently I use /mnt/hawi/... but I'm not sure if this ok.

 

Don't use /mnt/disks/ for anything.  UD manages that and can interfere as you found out.

[hawihoney 5]

What's the recommendation for own mount points?

 

In unRAID releases prior to 6.x I did use /boot/extras or something like that. What is the best place?

 

[Squid 1387]

3 hours ago, dlandon said:

Don't use /mnt/disks/ for anything.  UD manages that and can interfere as you found out.

Really?  Did not know that

 

It should be noted that if you add a mount point at /mnt then FCP will complain that it shouldn't be there and recommends to use /mnt/disks instead

 

[dlandon 273]

2 minutes ago, Squid said:

Really?  Did not know that

 

It should be noted that if you add a mount point at /mnt then FCP will complain that it shouldn't be there and recommends to use /mnt/disks instead

 

Normally not a problem, but is this case the user mounted a disk that was already set up by UD and when he deleted it, the mount got messed up.  I really don't think it is good idea regardless.

[Squid 1387]

1 minute ago, dlandon said:

Normally not a problem, but is this case the user mounted a disk that was already set up by UD and when he deleted it, the mount got messed up.  I really don't think it is good idea regardless.

/mnt is out because unRaid potentially manages everything in there with the exception of /mnt/disks.  Seems to me though (without reading the thread) that it's an edge case scenario, so I'll keep FCP recommending /mnt/disks, especially since if you're manually creating a mount point you should know not to have it interfere in the first place with any mounts created by UD.

[dlandon 273]

1 minute ago, Squid said:

/mnt is out because unRaid potentially manages everything in there with the exception of /mnt/disks.  Seems to me though (without reading the thread) that it's an edge case scenario, so I'll keep FCP recommending /mnt/disks, especially since if you're manually creating a mount point you should know not to have it interfere in the first place with any mounts created by UD.

Yea, the user can take that risk.  Why would someone want to mount anything manually anyway?  Doesn't UD handle just about every case of mounting things that is needed?  Only thing I can think of that isn't covered is a cloud mount.

[Squid 1387]

7 minutes ago, dlandon said:

Why would someone want to mount anything manually anyway?

In my case, muscle memory is the primary reason (I'm so used to typing /tmp/GitHub/...) to hit a desktop share.

 

Secondary reason for me at least is that (and I could be wrong here - can't confirm as someone is currently watching a stream) is doesn't UD umount everything at array stop? I don't necessarily want that.  But don't change it for me...  I'm an edge case

Edited February 12 by Squid

[dlandon 273]

26 minutes ago, Squid said:

doesn't UD umount everything at array stop?

Yes.  Could be messy if it doesn't.