so far looks like it was bad sata power splitter as i did try again after reseating the cables (i tried reseating cable again cause i realized that last time i mistakenly reseated cables of completely different drive😅) and now while rebuilding data it started throwing errors on disk 2, disk 2 and 3 are the ones that are connected through sata power splitter, so finally decided to pull the plug on sata power splitters and bought myself Gigabyte P750GM which comes with 8 sata connectors.
i dont know its just my bad luck or what, my history with SATA cables and power splitters has been quite troublesome. I found myself frequently reseating or replacing these cables every 2-3 months. About 6 or 7 months ago, I invested in an LSI 9207-8i, and since then, I haven't encountered a single issue related to SATA link speed or any other connectivity problems. Here's hoping that this new power supply will have a similar positive impact on my SATA power issues.