I put up a regular nginx container with the same ports, and I was able to connect to it fine. Removed the nginx container and recreated the LE container, and still had the same error, so i think my forwarding is fine.
I am having issues with my install. It was working a few months ago, but then it was turned off for awhile and I upgraded the OS twice and updated the Docker. It was no longer working, Everything seems to be set up correctly, and I never changed any of the settings. I tried recreating the docker and removing the appdata folder.