July 24Jul 24 Hi everyone,I'm new to Unraid and have been troubleshooting a performance issue for several hours. At this point I've ruled out many of the obvious causes and would appreciate another set of eyes.HardwareUGREEN DXP4800 GTUnraid 7.3.22 × WD Red Plus 8 TB SATADisk 1ParityCache: NVMe SSD (Btrfs)Mac mini running macOS 26.5.2Router: FRITZ!Box 6670 CableNAS connected via 1 Gbit EthernetMac connected via built-in Gigabit EthernetSymptomsCopying a large file (67 GB) from the Mac to Unraid:Transfer starts around 150–170 MB/sDrops to 0 MB/s for roughly 10–12 secondsResumesRepeats throughout the transferAverage throughput is only 30–60 MB/s.This happens:writing directly to the protected arraywriting to the cache SSDwith Finderwith cpwith scpSo it doesn't appear to be Finder-specific or cache-specific.What I've testedLocal disk performanceOn the NAS:dd if=/dev/zero of=/mnt/disk1/testfile bs=1M count=10000 status=progressResult:~200 MB/s sustained.This suggests the disks and filesystem are capable of normal write speeds.Networkethtool: 1000 Mb/s Full Duplex Link detected: yes Router also reports both Mac and NAS linked at 1 Gbit.System utilizationDuring transfers: CPU low RAM low Network not saturated Dashboard sometimes shows disk writes dropping to zero during the stalls. iostatDisk wait times appear normal (roughly 10–20 ms). I don't see obvious multi-second I/O waits.sarNetwork throughput averages roughly 30–35 MB/s during transfers.SMARTSMART appears healthy.QuestionHas anyone seen similar behavior on the DXP4800 GT or with Unraid 7.3.2?Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
July 25Jul 25 Community Expert Run an iPerf3 test from your windows pc to the server and confirm it’s not the networking.
July 25Jul 25 Community Expert I have a DXP2800 that I can fully saturate at least 1Gbps. Which I’ve done for a full duration of 9TB during a data backup session.This was strait to a btrfs raid1/mirror pool of 2x 12TB HDDsUnraid to unraid via restic over sftpThe one thing that can dramatically cut speeds is unraids FUSE layer, if you can bypass FUSE with an exclusive share it can greatly speed up copying. With that said FUSE seems to only be affected by many small files being read/wrote. A single large file shouldn’t really be an issue. Edited July 25Jul 25 by MowMdown
July 25Jul 25 Author 10 hours ago, MowMdown said:Run an iPerf3 test from your windows pc to the server and confirm it’s not the networking.Did that. From the Mac side I got about ~1400 retransmissions in about a 10s interval. 7 hours ago, MowMdown said:The one thing that can dramatically cut speeds is unraids FUSE layer, if you can bypass FUSE with an exclusive share it can greatly speed up copying. With that said FUSE seems to only be affected by many small files being read/wrote. A single large file shouldn’t really be an issue.Hmm.. Thing is, even on single large files, there's no difference in behavior when writing directly to the array or ssd cache pool. 8 hours ago, Led57 said:This is very normal. Same performance on my DXP4800 Plus.Can't imagine this to be normal to be honest. Especially as it results in average writing speeds of ~30mb/s.. That doesn't seem right at all. I've since created a Ticket with official support. I'll update this should we reach a fix for the problem. In the meantime I am grateful for any further ideas to fix this! :)
July 25Jul 25 Community Expert 2 hours ago, LrdSpn said:From the Mac side I got about ~1400 retransmissions in about a 10s interval.That sounds like a bad cable or a bad NIC port somewhere in the chain. This wont be an unraid issue. Edited July 25Jul 25 by MowMdown
July 26Jul 26 Author At this point I agree, that this is likely not an Unraid issue. I've changed cables, switched LAN ports on my router and made sure that every interface is communicating with the correct speeds (at least on paper). There seems to be something, most likely on the Mac side, limiting my connection to about 100mbit. The cables are brand new. So unless 3 cables I tried were all bad/damaged, that's not it.
July 26Jul 26 Community Expert do both devices and the router show link speeds negotiating at full speed?
July 29Jul 29 Author Found the issue. I was transferring data from an external SSD that was connected to my Mac. Not sure whats happening there since with the speed of the SSDs, it shouldn't make a huge difference, if any. Also not sure why I get these low iperf3 results with lots of retransmissions, but transfers look fine and fast now from my Macs internal SSD.
August 7Aug 7 Author Solution Quick update: I ran into this issue a few times more and it turns out that this is related to the Mac waking up from sleep mode. I don't know if it's because it can't recover the SMB/NFS state, TCP session, Ethernet interface or whatever else. But there's clearly something jammed after waking the Mac from sleep. I randomly noticed because I restarted my Mac at some point and that solved the issue. And the issue is reproducible. So if anyone else runs into that at some point. Restart your Mac/avoid using sleep mode.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.