Walt750 Posted January 28, 2020 Share Posted January 28, 2020 I have been testing unraid in trial mode for a few days. I copied files to a share (wired) to the server. I get about 105MB /sec, which is the same as my Raid 5 Array. It doesn't slow down and 20 gigs will scoot right along. Awesome! I try to read the same file back and it falls apart. I get anywhere from 15megs to 60 megs ... it's just all over the place. My unraid setup has 2 drives right now (Parity + Data). Is this transfer rate good for mutliple streams? I have a feeling that 2 x 4k streams will max it out. Am I looking at this correctly? Will it get worse as I add more drives? I don't have to worry about this on a 10 Drive Raid .... it just sings! Quote Link to comment
testdasi Posted January 29, 2020 Share Posted January 29, 2020 How did you "read the same file back"? Is there any other IO happening at the same time? With your current config, read should be the same speed as your data drive and write should be the slower of parity and data. When you add more data drives, your write speed should slow down but read speed should still be the same as that of whichever drive the data is on. If RAID is something that suits your needs, why would you move away from it? Can't have your cake and eat it. Quote Link to comment
Walt750 Posted January 29, 2020 Author Share Posted January 29, 2020 (edited) I love Cake.... don't you? After reading your comments, I decided to go back and re-run the file transfers. And the results were as good as my RAID 5 Setup. Well 98% anyway ... there were a tiny drops here and there. I'm not sure what happened the first go around. Oh ... and the main reason for wanting to move to Unraid .... it's the ability to just add storage space when I need it. On an regular raid ... I can't do that. I ran an 8Gb file cut/paste from the Raid 5 File Server to Unraid And then the reverse direction. At this point ... I'm sold! Thanks for your feedback! Edited January 29, 2020 by Walt750 Add more detail to answer a question Quote Link to comment
testdasi Posted January 29, 2020 Share Posted January 29, 2020 (edited) 8 hours ago, Walt750 said: I love Cake.... don't you? After reading your comments, I decided to go back and re-run the file transfers. And the results were as good as my RAID 5 Setup. Well 98% anyway ... there were a tiny drops here and there. I'm not sure what happened the first go around. Oh ... and the main reason for wanting to move to Unraid .... it's the ability to just add storage space when I need it. On an regular raid ... I can't do that. I ran an 8Gb file cut/paste from the Raid 5 File Server to Unraid And then the reverse direction. At this point ... I'm sold! Thanks for your feedback! That sounds like there were other IO's happening at the same time as when you last did the transfer. Because RAID stripes data, it helps with speed during simultaneous IO. Unraid will behave the same way as you have simultaneous IO on a single HDD i.e. slow. Edited January 29, 2020 by testdasi Quote Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.