Can't start array after replacing failed disk

[Bushido]

Hey guys, 

 

I recently bought 3 new 16TB drives to finally have 2 parity disks and add some capacity. After shutting down the server to add the drives and clean the server, I had a drive fail (10TB disk 2 in the screenshot). Since my new drives are larger than my largest drive in the parity, I added 1 of the new drives to the parity and it finished the parity rebuild today. Now, I'm trying to replace the failed drive, but any time I select one of the new drives, it won't allow me to start the array. Screenshot and diagnostics included. I'm hoping one of you guys can help. I've been running Unraid for years now, but am at a loss. If I click on Disk 2, there's an option to erase the drive, but I'm not sure if I need to select that or if that will cause irreparable harm. Thanks in advance

bushido-diagnostics-20240503-1844.zip

Edited May 3 by Bushido

[itimpi]

No data drive can be larger than the smallest parity drive so you cannot currently use a 16TB drive to replace the failed data drive as parity! Is only 12TB.

 

You can use the parity swap procedure to upgrade the parity1 drive to 16TB and then use the old parity1 drive to replace the failed drive.   It is specifically intended for this Use Case.

 

Alternatively you can simply upgrade parity1 to a 16TB drive and when that completes use another 16TB drive to replace the failed drive.

 

the first approach is definitely best if you want to end up with 3 data drives.

[Bushido]

For some reason I thought as long as you had a parity drive equal or greater than your largest drive, then it would work. That makes total sense. Thank you for taking the time to explain. It seems obvious in hindsight.