I use PIA while im browsing the internet and when im away from home I like to use Tailscale to access my unraid services. Trouble is in order to use tailscale I have to turn PIA off first as the two VPNs conflict.

To work around this I have tried to configure an exit node in unraid for my internet traffic but it either doesnt work or its really slow. I have tried a Gluetun container with PIA configured to use OpenVPN and I have just tried building an ubuntu VM and using Wireguard.

Am I missing something? Perhaps this wont ever work. Has anyone else done this?

8 hours ago, OrvilleWolf said:

Running two VPNs on the same device can definitely cause routing conflicts. One approach might be to use Tailscale's split tunneling or configure only specific traffic to go through PIA while leaving Tailscale traffic outside the VPN. It may also be worth checking whether the exit node is becoming a bottleneck due to encryption overhead or network settings. Hopefully someone who has successfully combined PIA and Tailscale on Unraid can share their configuration.

Yeah this is effectively what im after, Tailscale between my phone and home and PIA between home and internet.

Another option i havent tried is to build a Pi with ubuntu and PIA and set that as an exit node. That would take Unraid out of the solution, if its Unraid thats causing the problem. Id rather do it all on Unraid though if possible.

Try to disable "use tailscale dns" on your tailscale client on the phone. That should make it faster.