Thanks for the quick answer!
Ufff, I didn't quite realise that Disk 1 was not even showing temperature anymore..
I stopped the array, shutdown (this did not do anything, so I tried powerdown via the GUI bash). GUI went offline, but server stayed on, so I held the Power for 3+ seconds.
Opened up the server and it seemed mostly fine. Maybe one of the power cables came loose?
Now, back up, parity checking without errors and the shares are back. Let's see what happens, but it looks good so far!
Thank you again!