I am new to unRAID, and have built an array (v6) with a bunch of mostly new drives. One of them seems to be having problems (a 4TB WD Red, serial ending in VAX).
Background: I was in a hurry to try unRAID out so I only did one pass of pre-clear on each drive, and this ran with no problems for all drives. Everything was good until I tried to run a time-machine backup. I setup a time machine AFP share using only one drive (advice I'd seen on the forums), and this was on the 4TB WD Red. During the backup I got a lot of disk errors (I think they were read errors), and the backup failed. I left it at that (don't have much spare time to spend on this, and the TM backup wasn't urgent). A couple of days ago I swapped the SATA cables with another drive to determine whether it was a bad cable or port (I don't have spare cables, so swapping seemed like a logical approach). That day I got a write error message for the drive and it was kicked from the array. I sat down to work out what the problem was with the drive - to determine whether to RMA it.
I ran a short and long smart test, and each time they come back good. No bad / reallocated sectors, most things look ok to my uneducated eye. So, based on other forum posts I decided to try and rebuild the drive (I figured it would either work, or prove the drive was bad). I went through the process of de-assigning and re-assinging the drive, and started the re-build. It ran for a few hours then hit a whole load of write errors. This is where I am now. I downloaded the diagnostics, and took a look through them.
I want to RMA the drive, but the thing that's bugging me is that the SMART reports only list read errors, and doesn't mention any write errors. Could it be that the drive is good and the write errors are from a bad cable / SATA port. I just don't know how to tell. I don't want to send the drive back to Amazon and have them deem it's OK.
Can anyone offer advice on what to do to prove or disprove this is a bad drive? Are there any signs I'm missing in the SMART reports?
tower-diagnostics-20160507-0135.zip