February 3Feb 3 Here is a list of Tested USB Flash DrivesPlease use the following formatITEM: The USB Flash Drive Marketing NameSTORE: The Store purchasedWHEN: CCYY.MMPRICE:Package date markings:Package S/N markings:NOTES: Did the drive work, did it not work after some amount of time, anything else to noteCopy/Paste of the drive infoHere I'm using usbflashinfo by antspecThe most relevant info is:ManufacturerProductControllerMemory Chip(s) [lookup SLC, MLC, TLC, etc]VIDPIDPhysical Disk CapacityUSB VersionDeclared PowerMax Power Edited February 3Feb 3 by landS
February 3Feb 3 Author ITEM: SanDisk Cruzer Blade USB2.0STORE: SanDiskWHEN: 2024.10PRICE:Package date markings: 2022Package S/N markings: SDCZ50-032G-B35NOTES: Works great with UnraidController: SanDiskPossible Memory Chip(s): Not availableVID: 0781PID: 5567Manufacturer: SanDiskProduct: Cruzer BladePhysical Disk Capacity: 30784094208 BytesUSB Version: 2.00Declared Power: 200 mA Edited February 3Feb 3 by landS
February 3Feb 3 Author ITEM: PNY Attache 4 USB2.0 16GB:STORE: Amazon - B01193UP24WHEN: 2024.10PRICE: $22Package date markings: 2019Package S/N markings: P-FD16GATT4-GENOTES: Works great with UnraidController: Phison 2251-70Possible Memory Chip(s): Not availableVID: 154BPID: 00EEManufacturer: PNYProduct: USB 2.0 FDPhysical Disk Capacity: 31040995328 BytesUSB Version: 2.00Declared Power: 300 mA Edited February 3Feb 3 by landS
February 3Feb 3 Author ITEM: Kingston DT SE9 USB2.0 16GB:STORE: Amazon - B00DYQYITGWHEN: 2014.09PRICE: $9Package date markings: N/APackage S/N markings: N/ANOTES: Works great with UnraidController: Phison 2251-61 (2261)Possible Memory Chip(s):Toshiba TH58NVG7T2HTA20 [128G bit Nand Flash TLC]Toshiba TC58NVG6T2HTA00Memory Type: TLCVID: 0930PID: 6545Manufacturer: KingstonProduct: DataTraveler SE9Physical Disk Capacity: 15606349824 BytesUSB Version: 2.00Declared Power: 200 mA Edited February 3Feb 3 by landS
February 3Feb 3 Author ITEM: Samsung Drive FIT USB3.1 256GB:STORE: Amazon - B07D7Q41PMWHEN: 2019.03PRICE: $59Package date markings: N/APackage S/N markings: N/ANOTES: Within a year, issues booting in Unraid. Prone to overheating.Controller: UnknownPossible Memory Chip(s): Not availableVID: 090CPID: 1000Manufacturer: SamsungProduct: Flash Drive FITPhysical Disk Capacity: 256641603584 BytesUSB Version: 3.10Declared Power: 304 mA Edited February 3Feb 3 by landS
February 3Feb 3 Author ITEM: Samsung BAR Plus USB3.1 64GB:STORE: Amazon - B07BPKL2D2WHEN: 2024.10, 2022.06, 2022.03, 2021.01, 2020.07PRICE: (Latest) $24Package date markings: 2024.09Package S/N markings: MUF-64BE4/AMNOTES: Within a year, issues booting in Unraid for all 5 drives. Prone to overheating.Controller: UnknownPossible Memory Chip(s): Not availableVID: 04E8PID: 6300Manufacturer: SamsungProduct: Flash DrivePhysical Disk Capacity: 64160400896 BytesUSB Version: 3.10Declared Power: 304 mA Edited February 3Feb 3 by landS
February 3Feb 3 Thank you for posting.It's a good idea to mention the place and purchase date if available.I think the format can be improved by only keeping the most relevant info.Like the Brand Name/Model, USB interface, capacity in GB, date of puchase and/or date-related markings on the packaging if present, also the P/N and related markings from the back of packaging if just purchased. VID/PID, plus NAND ID and its interpretation by Google, Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT etc to get a confirmation on the reported NAND's type and process node size in nm. Also declared power or MaxPower.Your notes provide very interesting feedback on the drive's behavior in the actual Unraid machine, confirming that the USB 3.XX interface should be avoided.I'll make a similar attempt in a day or two, by sharing readouts from my older drives from the MLC era.
February 3Feb 3 ITEM: HP v150W USB2.0STORE: Office DepotWHEN: 2023.03PRICE WHEN PURCHASED: $5, current price $9 (drive I purchased was labelled as a 16GB flash drive, but, as seen below, it is almost 32GBNOTES: Works great with UnraidController: Phison PS2319Possible Memory Chip(s): Not availableFlash ID: 983E9803 76E4Chip F/W: 10.01.5DFirmware Date: 2022-07-19VID: 03F0PID: 2D40Manufacturer: HPProduct: v150wQuery Vendor ID: hpQuery Product ID: v150wQuery Product Revision: PMAPPhysical Disk Capacity: 31042043904 BytesWindows Disk Capacity: 31021137920 BytesInternal Tags: 2N2P-SX5LFile System: FAT32Relative Offset: 4032 KBUSB Version: 2.00Declared Power: 300 mA Edited February 3Feb 3 by Hoopster
February 3Feb 3 ^^Flash ID: 983E9803 76E4KIOXIA (formerly Toshiba) BiCS5 3D TLC NAND chipJust learned something new: "In modern 3D NAND like BiCS5, the "node size" (or process node/lithography) isn't quoted in the traditional planar 2D sense (e.g., "10 nm" or "15 nm" class), because scaling happens primarily vertically through layer count rather than shrinking the horizontal cell dimensions as aggressively."
February 8Feb 8 On 2/3/2026 at 10:57 AM, Lolight said:Just learned something new:"In modern 3D NAND like BiCS5, the "node size" (or process node/lithography) isn't quoted in the traditional planar 2D senseCorrect. The same is true in CMOS logic semiconductors as well. In planer logic, the node corresponded with an actual physical dimension of a transistor. Starting with 14nm, the industry moved from planer to FinFET, a 3D modeled transistor. The node then became a marketing tool, where they state what the theoretical size of a 2D planer chip would be for equivalent performance.And as the marketing departments tend to do, they one-upsmanship the competition. TSMC's 14nm was basically the same dimensions as Intel's 16nm.🤫
March 3Mar 3 ITEM: Transcend JetFlash 270M 8GBSTORE: PC-CanadaWHEN: 2026-02PRICE: $40 CADPackage date markings: None, brown boxPackage S/N markings: None, brown boxVolume: H:Controller: UnknownPossible Memory Chip(s): Not availableVID: 8564PID: 1000Manufacturer: JetFlashProduct: Mass Storage DeviceQuery Vendor ID: JetFlashQuery Product ID: Transcend 8GB Query Product Revision: 1100Physical Disk Capacity: 7722762240 BytesWindows Disk Capacity: 7705858048 BytesInternal Tags: JD2F-QADLFile System: FAT32Relative Offset: 124 KBUSB Version: 3.10Declared Power: 304 mAContMeas ID: AE1E-02-00Microsoft Windows 10 x64 Build 26200I've been using a Kingston DataTraveler 100 G3 since 2016, but recently I've been seeing some intermittent unreliability when booting, with checksum failures. Given the age of the USB drive, I figured it was worth replacing it with a new one for peace of mind.I wanted something with better-than-average reliability, but SLC or pSLC drives were a bit out of my budget. There's also a fairly limited selection of industrial/embedded drives that can be easily sourced, at least here in Canada.I was able to find this Transcend JetFlash 270M for a reasonable price (although still expensive per GB, of course). It's an industrial drive with MLC, and specifically states it has ECC -- I think this isn't uncommon, even in consumer drives, but it seems rare to have it explicitly stated. It also has a TBW rating, for the 8GB drive it's rated for 8 TBW, so 8000 full writes. That's a fairly low TBW rating compared to some other industrial drives, but still should be sufficient for many years of use.Unfortunately the drive info was unable to identify the controller or the memory, but I did find a datasheet that suggested it may be using 16nm Samsung MLC chips.I'm not sure that this is actually any better/more reliable than Transcend's consumer MLC drives like the JetFlash 780, but as the price was acceptable I figured I'd give it a go. I've not swapped Unraid over to it yet, but the USB installer suggests it has a unique GUID, so I'm not expecting any problems.
March 4Mar 4 8 hours ago, abirkill said:I've been using a Kingston DataTraveler 100 G3 since 2016ChipGenius is usually the better tool for the Controller info.Could you also please post a report from the Kingston for reference?It is very likely to have either Phison PS2251-03 or PS2251-07 controllers.Though I'm curious about the NAND.The 2016 DT100 G3 is right at the transition point- earlier units got Micron MLC which is decent, but later production runs and higher capacities switched to TLC, which is considerably worse for longevity.... might explain the errors you see. Edited March 4Mar 4 by Lolight
March 4Mar 4 8 hours ago, abirkill said:It's an industrial drive with MLC, and specifically states it has ECC -- I think this isn't uncommon, even in consumer drives, but it seems rare to have it explicitly stated.Marketing fluff..ECC has been a standard feature in virtually every NAND flash controller for decades — it's not optional, it's a necessity because NAND flash by its nature produces read errors that must be corrected in real time. No USB flash drive ships without it.
April 3Apr 3 Author ITEM: Swissbit Industrial U-500K SLC 8GB (SFU3008GE1AE1TO-I-DB-1A1-STD)STORE: DigiKeyWHEN: 2026.03PRICE: $388Package date markings: N/A - Arrived in LoosePackage S/N markings: N/A - Arrived in LooseNOTES: Drive presented a GUID, and Unraid USB Creator successfully installedManufacturer: SwissbitProduct: USB Flash KeyController: UnknownPossible Memory Chip(s): Not availableMemory Type: Not availableVID: 1370PID: 0501Physical Disk Capacity: 8019509248 BytesUSB Version: 3.10Declared Power: 296 mAMax Power: N/ADocumentation: Memory Type: Single-Level Cell (SLC) NAND FlashOperating Temperature Range:Commercial: 0 °C to 70 °CIndustrial: -40 °C to 85 °C
April 4Apr 4 22 hours ago, landS said:ITEM: Swissbit Industrial U-500K SLC 8GB (SFU3008GE1AE1TO-I-DB-1A1-STD)Appreciate the share! Seeing a Swissbit SLC here is a treat.The price is obviously overkill for a desk-side server, but for anyone running Unraid at a remote site this is the play. When a "truck roll" to go swap a failed consumer drive costs more than the hardware, paying for industrial SLC is just smart business. It’s the ultimate buy once, cry once boot drive.
April 29Apr 29 Author ITEM: Innodisk USB Drive 3ME (Pre-Flashed for LYTX DriveCam DVR-S70)STORE: Ebay 326046070546WHEN: 2026.04PRICE: $3.99Package date markings: N/A - Arrived in LoosePackage S/N markings: N/A - Arrived in LooseNOTES:1 - Drive presented a GUID, and Unraid USB Creator successfully installed2 - Had to be formatted before the flash drive was accessible3 - the Controller is 2013-era designed for 2x/2y/1x nm MLC and TLC flashFlash Drive Information Extractor 9.4.0.645:Manufacturer: InnodiskProduct: USB Drive 3MEController: Silicon Motion SM3261 ABPossible Memory Chip(s): Not availableMemory Type: Not availableVID: 196DPID: 0201Physical Disk Capacity: 64927825920 BytesUSB Version: 3.00Declared Power: 504 mAChipGenius:Flash ID code: 983C95937A51 - Toshiba - 2CE/Single Channel [MLC] -> Total Capacity = 64GBDocumentation:Memory Type: MLCOperating Temperature Range: -40 °C to 85 °CMax Power: 0.7W Edited May 1May 1 by landS
April 30Apr 30 Thanks for posting the USB info output. I'm assuming you've used the Flash Drive Information Extractor utility.Could you also run ChipGenius just to see if it shows any Flash ID info?Would you mind checking if any S.M.A.R.T data comes through? A quick way to test is via HWiNFOInnodisk has a S.M.A.R.T readout tool for their industrial USB drives called iTracker, designed specifically for USB drives -- it provides visualized S.M.A.R.T information, including P/E cycles and health status. But there's no "one-click" download on the main Innodisk site. It's managed through the MyInnodisk portal and requires registration.
May 1May 1 Author Hopefully it helps. I used Flash Drive Information Extractor 9.4.0.645ChipGenius Provides a Flash ID code: 983C95937A51 - Toshiba - 2CE/Single Channel [MLC] -> Total Capacity = 64GBHWiNFO is not being passed S.M.A.R.T data.I failed to find the S.M.A.R.T readout tool(set) on the innodisk site.It appears that myinnodisk access is granted to distributors & partners. Edited May 1May 1 by landS
May 1May 1 2 hours ago, landS said:ChipGenius Provides a Flash ID code: 983C95937A51 - Toshiba - 2CE/Single Channel [MLC] -> Total Capacity = 64GBThank you!Flash ID code: 983C95937A51it's Toshiba's A (Advanced) 19nm a "half-node" shrink of the original 19nm node.It's post-2016 production using 15 nm Toshiba MLC.Thanks again for providing that detailed NAND readout!Do you mind if I copy that output over to my MLC collection thread to archive specs for different MLC drives to keep all this technical data in one place.I’ll make sure to credit you for the dump. Edited May 4May 4 by Lolight
May 1May 1 Author You may copy the info.I'm just hoping to make finding stable usb drives easier for folks.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.