I was told through the unraid gui that i might have hardware problems.

 

 

tower-diagnostics-20171209-1044.zip

 

System:

Model: Custom

M/B: ASRock - EP2C602-4L/D16

CPU: Intel® Xeon® CPU E5-2670 0 @ 2.60GHz

HVM: Enabled

IOMMU: Enabled

Cache: 512 kB, 2048 kB, 20480 kB

Memory: 128 GB (max. installable capacity 192 GB)

Network: eth0: 1000 Mb/s, full duplex, mtu 1500 
 eth1: not connected
 eth2: not connected
 eth3: not connected

Kernel: Linux 4.9.30-unRAID x86_64

OpenSSL: 1.0.2k

 

In the log I notice there was errors regarding Ram Scrubbing?

Edited December 9, 20178 yr by deaerator

You might want to give the Gurus a bit more information about what hardware might have a problem and, if that is not available, a list of hardware that you have on the system. 

1 hour ago, deaerator said:

In the log I notice there was errors regarding Ram Scrubbing?

Searching through the syslog, there is no mention of "scrub"

 

1 hour ago, deaerator said:

I was told through the unraid gui that i might have hardware problems.

Any notification would have been through Fix Common Problems, and there is no record of FCP finding anything other than docker updates available.  What is this notification that you were talking about?

I will re-post a log when it shows up again. Last time the whole server crashed and I couldn't retrieve the log. 

1 hour ago, deaerator said:

I will re-post a log when it shows up again. Last time the whole server crashed and I couldn't retrieve the log. 

How often does the crash happen?  If its say daily, then throw FCP into troubleshooting mode.

It happens every 2-3 days. 

It gets very frustrating, sometimes i feel like junking and buy new hardware. 

A new log has been posted. 

FCP reports new hardware errors

tower-diagnostics-20171211-0710.zip

You have a bad memory DIMM

Thank you, 

How hard is that going to find?

 

Since you've got ECC, there may be clues in the BIOS (some sort of logging?) as to which DIMM is bad.  Beyond that, you can always pull them out one at a time and see what happens.

Nothing in the logs, thank you for the information. 

 

It will be a long day testing 16 sticks of ram with memtest

 

ECC errors on Supermicro boards are logged on the boards's event log, I would assume it would be the same with Asrock.

6 minutes ago, deaerator said:

It will be a long day testing 16 sticks of ram with memtest

 

With 16 sticks of RAM, You might want to make sure that your RAM is on the approved list.  (Sometimes, the control line drivers can't maintain the required waveform which can cause problems as the stick count goes up.) 

15 minutes ago, Frank1940 said:

 

With 16 sticks of RAM, You might want to make sure that your RAM is on the approved list.  (Sometimes, the control line drivers can't maintain the required waveform which can cause problems as the stick count goes up.) 

 

Where do I find this approved LIst?

 

The motherboard manufacturers website, under the support section for the specific board.

good to know,

 

Thank you.

Now it feels like a buyer beware kind of deal.

 

I purchased the Motherboard & Ram as a combo; made the assumption that it will work together. 

 

.

 

Turns out the ram is not the approved QVL, but it worked in my system for over a year, without any major problems until now.

 

 

 

Edited December 11, 20178 yr by deaerator

5 minutes ago, deaerator said:

but it worked in my system for over a year, without any major problems until now.

Memory can (and does) go bad.  No different than anything else.  QVL doesn't necessarily mean that the memory won't work with the mobo.  It simply means that if its on the list that it will work (if its not bad)

Edited December 11, 20178 yr by Squid

You could try pulling a couple of sticks (perhaps from each CPU bank) and see if that clears up the problem.  If it is a problem with the line drivers/RAM, that may fix the problem.  (I am not certain from what you wrote if you had any indication of a problem BEFORE you got the notice from Fix Common Problems.  If that is the case, the issue may always have been there but you just were not aware of it.  With EEC, A single bit read error should be detected and a reread should result which may return the proper data.  The system may be a bit slower but it probably won't crash and burn.)

I decided to do the slow and steady way, and test each stick individually.

Part of your problem though is that if you can't find this

1 hour ago, johnnie.black said:

ECC errors on Supermicro boards are logged on the boards's event log, I would assume it would be the same with Asrock.

 

then if the errors are being corrected properly a memtest will pass with flying colors and you will have done a ton of work with no results.

I seen zero errors in the event logs regarding Memory problems. 

Edited December 11, 20178 yr by deaerator

Then you need to talk to AsRock regarding this

Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: Hardware event. This is not a software error.
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MCE 0
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: CPU 8 BANK 8 
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MISC 1221020002000e8c ADDR 1e3872c000 
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: TIME 1512963915 Sun Dec 10 23:45:15 2017
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MCG status:
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MCi status:
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: Corrected error
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MCi_MISC register valid
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MCi_ADDR register valid
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MCA: MEMORY CONTROLLER MS_CHANNEL0_ERR
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: Transaction: Memory scrubbing error
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MemCtrl: Corrected patrol scrub error
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: STATUS 8c000047000800c0 MCGSTATUS 0
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: MCGCAP 1000c14 APICID 20 SOCKETID 1 
Dec 11 04:40:08 Tower root: CPUID Vendor Intel Family 6 Model 45

Memory scrubs are when the system attempts to read & write to every ram location during idle periods to see if the ram is good / bad.

Just fired off a support ticket.

ECC ram works like it should and no Errors showed up during the memtest.

 

I put Tower back together with 32Gb of ram and back online; Something seriously got borked overnight. 

 

Parity drives missing, call traces errors and cached drive disappeared.

 

 

tower-diagnostics-20171212-0533.zip

Edited December 12, 20178 yr by deaerator