I thought perhaps looking back in syslog to boot would reveal if you had unclean shutdown, but unfortunately boot time is not in the syslogs in diagnostics because your syslog is being spammed with these:
Sep 9 22:21:57 bigboi avahi-daemon[4724]: Record [0E59246677B6\064Attic\032SB\032Touch._raop._tcp.local#011IN#011SRV 0 0 40781 bigboi-2.local ; ttl=120] not fitting in legacy unicast packet, dropping.
Sep 9 22:21:57 bigboi avahi-daemon[4724]: Record [bigboi-2.local#011IN#011A 192.168.0.3 ; ttl=120] not fitting in legacy unicast packet, dropping.
Sep 9 22:21:57 bigboi avahi-daemon[4724]: Record [ABA7EBC51E26\064Kitchen\032SB\032Touch._raop._tcp.local#011IN#011TXT "42351" "tp=UDP" "sm=false" "sv=false" "ek=1" "et=0,1" "md=0,1,2" "cn=0,1" "ch=2" "ss=16" "sr=44100" "pw=false" "vn=3" "txtvers=1" "am=shairtunes2" ; ttl=4500] not fitting in legacy un
Sep 9 22:21:57 bigboi avahi-daemon[4724]: Record [ABA7EBC51E26\064Kitchen\032SB\032Touch._raop._tcp.local#011IN#011SRV 0 0 42351 bigboi-2.local ; ttl=120] not fitting in legacy unicast packet, dropping.
Sep 9 22:21:57 bigboi avahi-daemon[4724]: Record [_afpovertcp._tcp.local#011IN#011PTR bigboi-2-AFP._afpovertcp._tcp.local ; ttl=4500] not fitting in legacy unicast packet, dropping.
Sep 9 22:21:57 bigboi avahi-daemon[4724]: Record [bigboi-2-AFP._afpovertcp._tcp.local#011IN#011TXT ; ttl=4500] not fitting in legacy unicast packet, dropping.
Sep 9 22:21:57 bigboi avahi-daemon[4724]: Record [bigboi-2-AFP._afpovertcp._tcp.local#011IN#011SRV 0 0 548 bigboi-2.local ; ttl=120] not fitting in legacy unicast packet, dropping.
Any idea what that's about? It would make it difficult to figure out any other problems you might have.