In my experience some SMR disks work fine with Unraid, e.g., the Seagate drives I've have, both the 8TB Archive model as well as 4TB 2.5" drives, they are fast during a rebuild/sync and don't notice any big slowdowns during large sequential transfers (mostly large files, might be different with small files), on the other hand WD and Toshiba SMR drives behave normally during rebuild/sync but they get extremely slow during large transfers, even for large files.