OK, I see the problem now, disk2 has the same ID as disk3:
Nov 21 18:06:38 Petere kernel: ata10.00: ATA-10: OOS3000G, 00000000, 0001OOS1, max UDMA/133
Nov 21 18:06:38 Petere kernel: ata9.00: ATA-10: OOS3000G, 00000000, 0001OOS1, max UDMA/133
You can only use one of these with Unraid, and these are no standard Seagate drives, maybe white label?