Net time frame is the same.
My philosophy is that since the only time a disk gets disabled is when a write to it fails. At that point, the write gets reflected in the parity system. Because of that, as far as I'm concerned, the data on the drive is technically invalid since it was never updated to reflect that write, but since parity was, you're better off rebuilding the drive itself instead of doing a new config and rebuilding parity.
The write itself though may have been meaningless, so you're probably ok...