I recommend copying, not moving.
1. It's faster, ReiserFS is VERY slow to delete files, especially on very full or very well used volumes, and moving involves writing to both the source and destination where copying only involves writing on the destination, so parity is less busy.
2. After the copy is done, you can verify the results before you format the source to XFS.
You can use any method to copy that you are comfortable with, I personally use rsync at the command line, one pass for a quick copy, second pass with checksums for verification that the copy is complete.
These are the commands I used.
To copy
rsync -arv /mnt/disk(source)/ /mnt/disk(destination)
To verify
rsync -narcv /mnt/disk(source)/ /mnt/disk(destination)
Where (source) and (destination) are the literal numbers, like /mnt/disk12/
Be careful to include the slashes at the end where needed, otherwise you will end up with a root folder of disk12 with all your shares inside it, which can get VERY confusing since it will automatically show up as a share "disk12", but it will be on the destination disk, which is another disk number.
To use the command line for Unraid, there are MANY different ways to access it, but for your purposes my first choice would be the actual keyboard and monitor attached to the Unraid tower. 2nd choice would be a remote SSH session, and start a "screen" command before doing the copy and verify, that way if the session gets disconnected you aren't killing the copy.
Normally unbalance would work, but I suspect ReiserFS is causing your issues.
If you had pointed to your current thread where you were discussing your array failure with @johnnie.black, I would never have gone through the trouble of typing this up.
You really need to stop trying to move data around on the array, and copy anything important to good drives.